Is Moto2 To Blame for a Lack of Grip During MotoGP Races?

06/11/2014 @ 8:25 pm, by David Emmett8 COMMENTS

Is Moto2 To Blame for a Lack of Grip During MotoGP Races? Sunday Mugello Italian GP MotoGP Tony Goldsmith 10 635x422

It is a common complaint among MotoGP riders after the race on Sunday afternoon: the track never has the grip which the riders found on previous days during practice and qualifying.

The riders are quick to point the finger of blame at Moto2. The spectacle of 33 Moto2 machines sliding around on fat tires lays down a layer of rubber which adversely affects grip during the MotoGP race.

Andrea Dovizioso was the latest rider to add to a growing litany of complaints. After finishing sixth at Mugello, the Ducati rider told the media that the rubber laid down by Moto2 made it hard to obtain the same level of grip as they found during practice.

“Everybody complains about that,” Dovizioso said, “the rubber from Moto2 makes the grip less.” Because free practice and qualifying for Moto2 always takes place after MotoGP, but the Moto2 race happens before the premier class, it meant that track conditions were different.

Dovizioso was open to suggestions of reversing the order of practice for the Moto3 and Moto2 classes, with Moto2 preceding MotoGP and Moto3 following, rather than the other way round, Moto3 practice taking place ahead of MotoGP, and Moto2 going last.

The idea behind this would be to have MotoGP practicing in the same conditions as the race, once Moto2 have left their layer of rubber on the track. “It would be an interesting test if Moto2 and Moto3 would swap,” Dovizioso said.

It is a suggestion which Jorge Lorenzo’s team manager Wilco Zeelenberg has also made on a number of occasions, the Dutchman have complained of differing grip conditions repeatedly for several years now.

But are MotoGP’s grip problems really caused by having to race after Moto2? Or are there other factors at play, which are not being taken into account?

To get an expert opinion, we asked legendary Tech 3 crew chief Guy Coulon. As crew chief for Tech 3′s MotoGP and Moto2 riders, Coulon has experience and understanding of both classes, and how setup for the bikes changes over the three days of practice.

Coulon is not convinced that Moto2 is what is causing the different grip conditions for the MotoGP race. “Grip for the Moto2 race [at Mugello] was also less,” Coulon said. Having extra rubber on the track could be a contributing factor, but there were many other factors to be taken into consideration.

As ground temperature goes up, so grip comes down, Coulon explained, with temperatures usually different on Sunday than preceding days. “Riders were already complaining about the grip during the short practice session [FP4] on Saturday afternoon,” he said.

There is another, less intuitive reason why riders don’t experience the same levels of grip on Sunday, according to Coulon. During practice, riders spend most of their time on their own, working on a perfect lap. During the race, that is simply not possible.

“In the race, the riders are following, so they can’t ride their own style,” Coulon told us. During the race, riders are concentrated on the other bikes around them, rather than on themselves.

They are looking for places to pass those ahead of them, defend against those behind them, or are following the lines of the riders in front. That is a crucial difference, forcing riders to ride differently, and meaning that they spend a lot of their time taking different lines during practice. The feeling of grip is different because they are riding differently, Coulon believes.

The most convincing argument for Coulon, however, is the feeling of the track during the tests. If the rubber laid down by Moto2 is a problem for grip, why does a track always have more grip during a test after the race.

“Why was there more grip on Monday morning after the Jerez race?” Coulon wondered rhetorically. The track has a layer of rubber from all three races, which in theory should mean it has even less grip. And yet riders usually say they have more grip on Monday than they have had all weekend. If rubber was a problem, then tests on Mondays should be worse, not better.

Photo: © 2014 Tony Goldsmith / TGF Photos – All Rights Reserved

This article was originally published on MotoMatters, and is republished here on Asphalt & Rubber with permission by the author.

Comment:

  1. Damn says:

    “Why was there more grip on Monday morning after the Jerez race?” Coulon wondered rhetorically.

    Don’t wonder Coulon. its simple…. MotoGP is the last race, thats why monday riders have more grip.

  2. smiler says:

    It is perhaps the arguement of grey haried old men but – back in my day…..

    Did Sheene, Roberts, Doohan, Hailwood, Ago and others blather on about differences between practice and race day.
    How about understanding the difference in grip, which can also be caused by rain, change in termperature overnight moisture, degree of humidity and get on with racing…….

    It seems a bit like the people who buy a house near a race track then moan about the noise?

    If Moto3 and 2 were after the MotoGP race, no one would watch.

  3. JHB1984 says:

    +1 to what “smiler” wrote

  4. BBQdog says:

    I don’t see the problem. Just change the order of the races to Moto3, MotoGP, Moto2 and problem solved.
    The most exiting class first, the most boring last, the most predictable in the middle.

  5. Ken C. says:

    Riders will ALWAYS complain about grip, no matter what the conditions are. When have riders ever praised the amount of grip from tire manufacturers and tracks. Never. Their job is to push the limits of the technology, but they always complain when they find it.

    I feel sorry for Bridgestone, and don’t blame them for leaving MotoGP. And now Michelin, who will have to endure the complaints going forward.

  6. jacob says:

    As far as i know it was “the more tire rubber, the more grip”. So whats the point? Do they mean there is a point where there is too much rubber, in which way the grip decreases, or is the theory that there is a significant difference in the rubber layed down by the different classes?

  7. david says:

    i think the problem is more down to the moto 2 bikes putting down different rubber, as they run on dunlops and not bridgestones. usually more rubber improves grip, as you hear riders complaining when a track is too “green”. perhaps if moto 2 and moto gp ran on the same tires? not likely, what tire manufacturer would undertake that?

  8. Westward says:

    One would think they would have studied this over the years. Hire,three different groups to scientifically assess the issue then report. Intelligent conclusions can then arrive.

    However, it is interesting that the grip seems better after a race weekend. But then too, the conditions and circumstances are different after ten or twelve hours, oppose to two or three.