A Prelude to MotoGP’s Silly Season, Part 2

04/08/2014 @ 3:47 pm, by David Emmett8 COMMENTS


This is the second part of our two-part series on how the silly season for next year’s MotoGP rider line up may play out. If you missed the first part, you can catch up with the situation in the Honda and Yamaha factory teams here.

Up until late in the 2013 season, changes in the rider lineup for Yamaha and Honda’s MotoGP squads looked to be limited. Though all four riders will technically be on the open market at the end of 2014, the most likely scenarios for 2015 and beyond looked fairly settled.

Either the lineups of the Repsol Honda and Movistar Yamaha teams would remain identical, or Jorge Lorenzo and Dani Pedrosa might swap seats. The biggest question mark, it appeared, hung over whether Valentino Rossi would continue racing after 2014.

Two major shake ups changed all that. For Valentino Rossi, the replacement of Jeremy Burgess with Silvano Galbusera – and the increased role for electronics engineer Matteo Flamigni – has helped him find at least some of the time he was losing to the three Spaniards who dominated MotoGP last year, making it more likely he will stay on at Yamaha for another couple of seasons. That leaves the situation at Yamaha look more stable than before.

The biggest change, though, came at Ducati. The top of the entire Ducati Corse department underwent radical change. Gigi Dall’Igna was brought in to replace Bernhard Gobmeier as head of Ducati Corse, while Davide Tardozzi joined Paolo Ciabatti and Ernesto Marinelli to help manage the MotoGP and World Superbike teams.

The arrival of Dall’Igna and Tardozzi has had a major impact, and will likely become even more significant as the season progresses. Dall’Igna has greatly improved communications between staff at Ducati’s Bologna headquarters and the race teams at the track, making for a much more efficient organization.

That has combined with design improvements made over the winter to create a more competitive Desmosedici. Those design changes were for the most part made under the direction of former Ducati Corse director Gobmeier, but have greatly improved front-end feel on corner entry, and given a bit more grip on corner exit.

Major problems remain – the engine is still too aggressive and the bike still suffers badly with understeer – but Dall’Igna has said he hopes to start to address those problems after the first four races.

All these changes have made Ducati a completely different proposition. When Valentino Rossi left Ducati at the end of 2012, a seat in the factory Ducati team looked like the kiss of death for a MotoGP racer’s career.

Over a year later, with the palace revolution at Ducati complete, the Italian factory is suddenly looking like a shrewd gamble. The bike is already looking much more competitive, with the promise of much, much more to come.

When Cal Crutchlow announced his switch to Ducati for 2014, many fans bemoaned his lack of judgment. As the situation at Ducati continues to improve, his move looks less and less like a risky gamble, and more like a canny investment in the future.

It is typical of Crutchlow’s career: the Englishman has repeatedly made career moves which many felt were unwise at the time he made them, but which paid off in the long term. Though he has made a modest start at Ducati, the progress shown by teammate Andrea Dovizioso shows that the bike can be competitive, and it is only likely to get better.

The improvement of the Ducati has transformed their position in the rider market. By the end of his first season with Ducati, Andrea Dovizioso looked worn down, tired of waiting for results and resigned to sitting out his contract. After the first test at Sepang, the Italian looked happier and more motivated than he had for a whole year.

Like the riders at Yamaha and Honda, Dovizioso’s contract runs out at the end of this season, but remaining where he is now is a viable option. Cal Crutchlow is signed through 2015, but the Englishman has an option to leave at the end of this year, a safety measure put in place just in case Ducati didn’t make the progress he had hoped for.

So while Ducati is looking a more attractive option for their two current riders, they are also better placed to attract both existing and fresh talent. Gigi Dall’Igna is rumored to be making a strong push to sign Jorge Lorenzo, as having a world champion on the bike would help speed up both development and competitiveness of the Desmosedici.

Though getting Lorenzo to switch to Ducati could prove to be impossible, there are other young talents who could be persuaded to make the switch. If Aleix Espargaro continues to show his current form, the Spaniard could also be a strong option for the Italian factory. And then there’s Andrea Iannone: already signed to race for Ducati with Pramac, if his strong form continues in 2014, he could also be an option for the factory Ducati team.

In the past, Ducati has also shown an interest in Stefan Bradl. The German is in his third season with the LCR Honda team, where he has built up a strong bond with team owner Lucio Cecchinello. Bradl scored his first pole and podium in 2013, yet HRC felt he had not fully lived up to expectations.

The pressure is on Bradl to become a more regular podium finisher in 2014 if he is to retain his seat with LCR. Success with LCR could also increase his appeal to Ducati, however, leaving LCR in turn with a vacancy to fill. Whether Ducati would prefer Bradl over either of their two current riders is open to question.

The real wild card in the 2015 silly season is Suzuki. The Japanese factory is continuing to work on their return to MotoGP next year, with development stepping up pace. Question marks remain over their progress, however. The XRH-1, as the inline four machine is known, is still well over a second off the pace of the front runners.

Part of that deficit is down to porting the software from their proprietary Mitsubishi electronics systems across to the spec Magneti Marelli system. Given how quickly HRC managed the same task, that casts doubt over the resources Suzuki is investing in their project. With spec software to be imposed for 2016 and beyond, that should make things easier for Suzuki, and allow them to concentrate their resources on improving the motorcycle.

The Suzuki MotoGP bike will be the real gamble for next season. Randy De Puniet has already bet his future career on being a Suzuki test rider, working to help develop the bike ready for its return. He is hoping that Suzuki will reward him for the work he has already put in by promoting him to a full factory ride in 2015. Others will also have their eye on Suzuki.

If the bike proves to be faster than the Ducatis as the year progresses, Dovizioso or Crutchlow may want to make the leap. Alvaro Bautista is set to lose his ride to Scott Redding at the end of 2014, and Bautista’s history with Suzuki would also make him a strong candidate. Then there’s Bradley Smith or Aleix Espargaro, or perhaps even Stefan Bradl.

Some of the top World Superbike riders also have their sights on the factory Suzuki ride. Eugene Laverty is set to test the bike later in the year, the Irishman having made it clear that he would welcome a return to the Grand Prix paddock, but only on a competitive bike.

Jonathan Rea has also expressed an interest in a switch to MotoGP, though again, his condition is that he is only interested in a move on a competitive bike. Suzuki could be an option for Rea, but the Pata Honda rider could also be angling for Stefan Bradl’s ride, if the LCR Honda seat becomes vacant.

What Suzuki really needs is a proven champion, but that looks an impossible dream for the Japanese factory. In its current state, they stand no chance of attracting Jorge Lorenzo, Dani Pedrosa, or Marc Marquez. Though the Suzuki team is being run by Davide Brivio, long-time friend and confidant of Valentino Rossi, Rossi will not make the switch either.

At this stage in his career, Rossi has no interest in another gamble, and the long-term relationship he has built with Yamaha will surely prove more lucrative than any switch to another manufacturer.

Right now, everything in MotoGP is wide open, with nothing signed and talks only at the stage where riders, factories and teams are expressing an interest in each other. But with so much at stake, and so much up for grabs, negotiations will start early, and will carry on for a long time.

Despite silly season kicking off so very early this year, finalizing the 2015 rider line up could take much longer. With so many options open, the permutations are many and varied. This one could run and run.

Photo: © 2014 Scott Jones / Scott Jones Photography – All Rights Reserved

This article was originally published on MotoMatters, and is republished here on Asphalt & Rubber with permission by the author.

  • proudAmerican

    Whether he finds himself still sitting atop his Movistar Yamaha, or Dani’s Respsol Honda in 2015, Lorenzo is going to get a very, very big pay raise.

  • Lewis Dawson

    Maybe this is too simplistic, but as I understand it, the Honda responds best to point-and-shoot riding, but Lorenzo’s style is for mid-corner speed requiring max edge grip. And because of the current tires, the Yamaha also needs a more point-and-shoot style, but Lorenzo is unable to give that, which compounds the Honda speed advantage. So maybe JL99 going over to the Honda camp would put him on a bike that doesn’t really suit his riding style. Maybe better to work on developing the Yamaha. Maybe Jorge will only see the salary numbers offered, but I hope sporting prospects are also important to him.

  • M

    In a more perfect world, Yamaha would have Michelins and/or Dunlops etc to choose from, Dorna would allow more than just 22 slots, Suzuki and Aprilia and Kawasaki and BMW and others would all join in to fill the grid with bikes that so many quality riders could flog to their limits.

  • M

    And there wouldn’t be such ridiculously draconic engine and/or fuel limits.

  • L2C

    As I said at the time he left Ducati, the best thing that Valentino Rossi did for Ducati was to sign with them and fail. And then leave. That was the beginning of brighter days for the factory.

    I’m sure it didn’t feel great at the time, but Rossi and Jeremy Burgess did a great thing by exposing the factory’s weaknesses beyond a shadow of a doubt. In my opinion, and I’m serious about this, both deserve some sort of formal/informal recognition by Ducati for the work that they did there. It would be unusual, but together they were the primary reason why Ducati is now enjoying the early stages of a renaissance.

  • smiler

    Alvaro Bautista is set to lose his ride to Scott Redding at the end of 2014 – great news so we can look forward to races that are not crash strewn.

    As for Ducati – much eating of words is likely to be done by the end of this season by thiose and there are many who banged on about how useless Ducati was and more importantly how stupid Cal was to make the move.
    Audi said results by 2015 – so it will be 2015.

  • H.L.

    I really would prefer if Lorenzo and Marquez continue to battle with their current manufacturers and not as teammates. However, anyone who thinks Lorenzo’s style isn’t suited for the Honda isn’t thinking it through carefully. It’s much easier to adapt from a “early braking, mid-corner speed, longer time spent on edge” style, to riding a “point and shoot” bike, than vice-versa.

    I think Bautista is a good guy at heart but Redding will eventually make him look bad when he gets enough seat time on the Gresini Honda Satellite bike next year or 2016.

    If Suzuki is smart and really wants to capitalize on this silly season, they’ll thank RdP with a nice check and send him on his way in a classy manner of course. No need to waste a seat and precious time. Also, if they don’t lock up two good riders soon, they’ll most likely become Aprilla riders in 2016.

  • Westward

    Such an expert on Lorenzo but clueless about DePuniet. DePuniet put that LCR Honda on the front row several times while he was on it and got couple of podiums too. Were he on a Factory HRC ride like Simoncelli or Bautista, he might have even won a few races too…

    I’d even like to see what he could do on a newly engineered Ducati.

    Cal Crutchlow made the best move possible. The potential and the pay were well worth it. Anyone who didn’t see that is jaded…